JAMB 2019 English Language · Question 25

If he had spoken up, he wouldn't have been given. This means that

Options

  1. A.he spoke up and was given
  2. B.he wasn't given because he spoke up
  3. C.he didn't speak up and wasn't given
  4. D.he was given because he didn't speak up

Answer: D. he was given because he didn't speak up

Explanation written with AI and checked against the answer key

Analyze the question

The sentence "If he had spoken up, he wouldn't have been given..." is a third conditional (past unreal conditional). It talks about something that did not happen in the past and its imagined result.

Concept

Third conditional: If + past perfect, would (not) have + past participle.

  • It always implies the opposite of what is stated.
  • The "if" clause (had spoken up) means he did not speak up.
  • The result clause (wouldn't have been given) means he was given.

So the real situation is: He didn't speak up, and he was given.

Step-by-step solution

  1. "If he had spoken up" → in reality, he did not speak up.
  2. "He wouldn't have been given" → in reality, he was given (something).
  3. The sentence links the two: because he didn't speak up, the result happened. That is, he was given because he didn't speak up.

Checking the options

  • A. He spoke up and was given. ✗ He did not speak up.
  • B. He wasn't given because he spoke up. ✗ Reverses both facts.
  • C. He didn't speak up and wasn't given. ✗ He was given, not "wasn't given".
  • D. He was given because he didn't speak up. ✓ Matches both reversed facts and the cause-and-effect link.

Tip

For third conditional "meaning" questions, reverse both parts: positive becomes negative and negative becomes positive. "Had spoken" → "didn't speak"; "wouldn't have been given" → "was given". Then join them with "because".

AI can make mistakes. Report anything that looks wrong.

Past questions © the examination body (JAMB/WAEC/NECO). DeeepSolve is not affiliated with them. Rights holders: see /copyright.