JAMB 2015 English Language · Question 38

Toyosi arrived late, --------------- the right route

Question

From the options, choose the word(s) that best filll the gap. Toyosi arrived late, --------------- the right route

  1. A.Cannot have taken
  2. B.Could not have take
  3. C.could not had taken
  4. D.could not have taken

Answer: D. could not have taken

Explanation written with AI and checked against the answer key

Analyze the question: The sentence is "Toyosi arrived late, __ the right route." The gap needs a verb form that explains why she was late. The logical meaning is that she probably did not take the right route, so we need a modal perfect (a modal verb plus have plus the past participle) to express a past deduction.

Concept: To make a deduction or guess about a past event, we use:

modal (could / must / might / cannot) + have + past participle

  • Example: He could not have seen me.
  • The past participle of "take" is taken, not "take" or "took".

Checking each option:

  • A. Cannot have taken – The form is grammatical. However, "cannot" is present tense and does not fit well with the past-tense narration ("arrived"). It also gives the wrong meaning here, since "cannot have taken the right route" would be a firm conclusion rather than a matching past-tense expression. The sequence of tenses points to "could".
  • B. Could not have take – Wrong, because "take" should be the past participle "taken".
  • C. could not had taken – Wrong, because after a modal we use "have", not "had".
  • D. could not have taken – Correct. The modal is past (could), followed by "have" and the past participle "taken".

Full sentence: Toyosi arrived late, could not have taken the right route. In standard written English a connecting word or comma structure would normally be used, but among the options, D is the only one that is both grammatically correct and consistent in tense with "arrived".

Note: the sentence as printed is a bit awkward, and the meaning could even be read as "she arrived late because she did not take the right route".

Exam tip: Remember the formula modal + have + past participle. Whenever you see "could/should/would/must/might + ___", check two things: that "have" (not "had" or "has") follows the modal, and that the main verb is in its past participle form (taken, seen, gone, written).

AI can make mistakes. Report anything that looks wrong.

Past questions © the examination body (JAMB/WAEC/NECO). DeeepSolve is not affiliated with them. Rights holders: see /copyright.